Where’s the Money?: Trump’s Stance on Public Housing
At the Republican National Convention a video showed multiple NYCHA residents who are considered community leaders appear to speak in favor of President Donald Trump and instead cast blame for NYCHA’s woes onto Mayor Bill de Blasio.
Though the video has been widely discredited, with the interviewees even speaking out, this has created a tremendous amount of confusion.
- NYCHA tenants say they were misled into RNC video appearance, Brooklyn Eagle.
- N.Y.C. Tenants Say They Were Tricked Into Appearing in R.N.C. Video, NYTimes.
- NYCHA Resident Leaders Who Appeared In RNC Video Clarify That They Don’t Support Trump, Gothamist.
So where does Trump stand on public housing?
Consistent Attempts to Slash the Budget
Every year a new budget is released by Congress. That budget is informed by a budget proposal that comes from the sitting President. Looking at Trump’s yearly budget proposals for public housing tells us a lot about where he stands on public housing.
There are two lines to look at:
- The public housing capital fund is the money that goes towards making repairs, modernization, and retrofitting buildings for climate change.
- The public housing operating fund is the money that goes towards administering services and managing the developments.
When Trump came into office in 2017, he proposed cutting the capital fund by $1.3 billion and the operating fund by $600 million.
In 2018, he proposed the same cuts.
In 2019, he proposed merging the two funds into one and reducing overall funding.
In 2020, he proposed eliminating the capital fund and reducing the operating fund by nearly $1 billion, or 21%.
Each year it is congress that has rebuffed these severe cuts, keeping funding largely stable.
Consistent Expansion of RAD program
Another indicator of where Trump stands on public housing is his approach to RAD. RAD, or rental assistance demonstration, was just that when it was created by Obama in 2012 – a demonstration. It was a pilot program designed to explore the use of private funds in the management of public housing buildings, and there was a cap on the number of units that could be effected nationwide: 60,000.
In 2015, the Obama administration increased the cap to 185,000 units nationwide, and again to 225,000 units in 2017.
Trump continued this trend – expanding the cap to 455,000 units in 2017, and calling to eliminate the cap in 2021.
Why does this matter? RAD is a program that privatizes public housing units and brings in private managers who are in the business of profiting off of property.Posted on: September 5, 2020